Welcome

Welcome to my writings or rants or whatever. Primarily these pages contain content of particular relevance to people in Saint Paul, Minnesota.

There are some links on the right which people in Saint Paul might find helpful.

If you feel inspired enough to publicly [although the particular public is not very big] comment on anything I have written, a place is provided. PLEASE GIVE ME A NAME OF YOUR CHOICE [as long as you don't use somebody else's] AND YOUR NEIGHBORHOOD [to help give identity and establish perspective]. I reserve the right to continue to delete as I see fair and proper.




Thursday, July 10, 2008

Franken as panderer

Al Franken want to forbid former congresspeople from ever becoming lobbyists and is spending a lot of money letting us know that. I question whether that is good policy, but really don’t need to write about my reservations, because it won’t happen. If you can believe that proposal has a chance of coming about, you probably could be led to believe that George Carlin was runner-up to Cardinal Ratzinger in the Sistine Chapel in 2005.

It won’t happen. It is so pathetically predictable that politicians will pander to us and Franken is just doing his part.

Politicians, especially non-incumbents, take on lobbyists and “special interests.” Other professions also have professionally-mandated positions to take which we also expect to hear.

Preachers rail against sin. Dentists advocate flossing. Librarians urge reading. Safety commissioners push seat belt usage. Aging sluggers who don’t have good legs anymore advocate the designated hitter rule. Teachers support learning, at least learning the right things.

We expect these things. But on these things, there is an outside chance that these some one’s actions might actually be changed. Some sins might not be committed when the exhortations of preachers are taken to mind. Some teeth may be flossed because of a dentist’s ongoing urgings. Some poor sap who otherwise is not scared by “buckle up” laws might actually click a seat belt together because his government suggests it so persistently. Sucker sports fans will continue to come and root for guys who really are no longer baseball players. Somebody may help their child or grandchild or neighbor with his/her lessons.

But there ain’t no way that Congresspeople and Senators are going to limit their future employment opportunities for the rest of their lives. It just ain’t a going to happen. Franken knows that. [And if he doesn’t he shouldn’t be in the position of being considered a serious candidate for any office, much less a major one.]

But people of any party can pander and Al Franken is demonstrating this well.

2 comments:

Anonymous said...

A lifetime ban is too much to ask. And it might be a violation of ex post facto, to forbid somebody from holding a job because of what he had been.

Anonymous said...

It’s not quite ex post facto and it really isn’t a bill of attainder either. Both of these were prohibited by the constitution even before the bill of rights was added.

But unless you limited the sanction to future members of Congress it wouldn’t seem right. And passing something that way which would exempt all of them would probably really smell.

But I think a lifetime ban is too serious, regardless of how it is implemented. What Franken is also missing is how he would include those former congressmen and women who are lawyers from representing clients who have interests at the Capitol. They really aren’t considered lobbyists now and enjoy certain reporting and tax advantages that non-lawyer lobbyists do not have.

Cherokee Park lawyer