Welcome

Welcome to my writings or rants or whatever. Primarily these pages contain content of particular relevance to people in Saint Paul, Minnesota.

There are some links on the right which people in Saint Paul might find helpful.

If you feel inspired enough to publicly [although the particular public is not very big] comment on anything I have written, a place is provided. PLEASE GIVE ME A NAME OF YOUR CHOICE [as long as you don't use somebody else's] AND YOUR NEIGHBORHOOD [to help give identity and establish perspective]. I reserve the right to continue to delete as I see fair and proper.




Saturday, March 29, 2008

In honor of Viet Nam veterans


The legislature has proclaimed today Viet Nam Veterans Appreciation Day. While at the rate we get into wars may soon give us more occasions for veterans’ appreciation than we have days on the calendar, this gesture seems to make sense and was overdue. So let’s give today proper attention.

I have been around for a while. Some of the people I have known were killed in Viet Nam. I have been to the funerals of both war victims and veterans and have shared sympathy with survivors.

Every generation seems doomed to have its war. Some wars seem to unify the country; others divide it; yet others seem to bring about a sense of ennui.

People of my parents’ generation fought World War Two. Records show that the soldiers and sailors returning from there were greeted by a grateful nation. I remember seeing my cousin off to and back from Korea when I was a young boy and know that the whole extended family was glad to see him. I was too young to appreciate anything like national sentiment, but have suspected that, likely because the war never really ended and the survival of our republic had never been seen as so directly challenged, their reception was somewhat less enthusiastic than that received by the World War Two vets, but that individual veterans were relatively well received.

We seem to have done a better job of welcoming those retuning from Desert Storm and even those coming back from our present adventures/misadventures in Iraq, Afghanistan, and Bosnia.

But somewhere the Viet Nam vet never quite got the appreciation those before or since have received. You would sometimes read about a vet being spit upon at the airport when he returned or having his family called by strangers suggesting that he was some kind of war criminal.

American participation in the Viet Nam war was unjustified from the beginning, but that doesn’t mean that those who had to go there thought it was a good idea. They were mainly people who had been conscripted or enlisted to avoid conscription, disproportionately working class and minority people. They did what they were told to do and generally did it quite well. But it wasn’t their idea.

I have my own personal story of one man’s return from Viet Nam which still gives me pause.

It had to be about 1971, give or take a year. I was driving cab and picked up a young man at the airport. He was carrying an Army duffel bag [or whatever they call one of those in the Army – I am not good on military vernacular] and gave me a destination off Highway 55 in Mendota Heights or Eagan.

While I was driving him there, I learned that he had just returned from Viet Nam. We did a little small talk about how he must be glad to be back and what a nice, sunny day he had for his return. It seemed me to be a sign of something wrong that nobody had come to greet him, but I don’t remember saying anything about it to him. And for all I know he had been wishing to surprise his kith and kin so had not told them the details of his arrival.

When we go to his house, I went to the trunk to retrieve his bag and noticed that there was a shirtless man who looked like he was probably the younger man’s father who was mowing the lawn.

The young man said something to the effect of “hello” and the older man stopped his mowing long enough to address him by name and say something like, “Oh, you’re back.”

The younger man took his bag on past the older guy who had resumed mowing and went toward the house.

I don’t know whether the man was indeed the young man’s father or not. He could have been a neighbor, relative, or family friend, but he obviously knew the guy and must have known where he had been.

But he couldn’t even stop mowing that lawn long enough to help him in or offer anything more than perfunctory greetings. That lawn didn't look that high.

2 comments:

Anonymous said...

I had an uncle who I never met who never came back from there. He probably could have gotten out of it but didn’t for some reason. My grandparents were better off and he probably could have hid out in college, but he wouldn’t do it. He would have graduated in 1973 if he had gone to college.

My grandmother never did really accept his death and always said that she had begged him not to sign up. My grandfather would never talk about it at all.

Studying that war years later when I was in school makes me wonder what its purpose was or whether we ever knew we even had one. And even though our family was hit, I know that it was still people of lesser opportunities who got hit the worst and that an affluent girl like me would have had no worries.

R Sammons said...

I wish you had not commented anonymously. I really prefer having the idea[s] that a label imposes. But since so few anonymous posts have been offensive or off topic enough to require deletion.

You are right bringing it to my attention that the deceased were not the only victims of the Viet Nam misadventure, nor are they of any war, but the deceased were certainly in some way more victims than the others.

My condolences to you and your family [including your grandparents if they are still living, although your use of past tense would indicate that they probably no longer with us].

There has been some talk about returning to conscription. Even though I know that I am not of conscriptable age or physical condition, I am against it, but do acknowledge that there is more class inequity in how our military is staffed than there was then.

But I believe that conscription is involuntary servitude and is banned by the Thirteenth Amendment and also simply has never been [and likely cannot ever be] instituted fairly. You noted that your uncle could have probably gotten out of the draft and also alluded to the fact that your gender would have automatically excluded you from consideration. Had I not gone to college, I likely could have ended up there. As it was, by the time I had graduated I had learned of a medical condition that made me unacceptable to the drafters which would not have been noticeable when I was eighteen. And even at that I did go through my year of being draft-eligible, I had the luck of having a low-rated birth date. [A person born at the same time as I in a time zone further west would not have been so lucky. So much for “equal justice under law.”]

The draft was so unevenly applied with is exemptions, geographical administration, deferments, and uneven administration of physical and mental requirements, never mind its gender discrimination and I do not know how it could ever be done fairly.